Finally, I can get around to writing these 'offseason grades' posts. All of the major dominoes have apparently fallen, except for maybe Kawhi, who can't seem to stop tripping over his own shadow type shit.
BOSTON CELTICS: C-
I know that Boston has the tendency to overachieve, and they have some solid players, but honestly, I'm not expecting much out of this roster. First of all, it's mostly reliant on Jayson Tatum who, for all we know, may never be able to play over long stretches again.
More notably, let's not forget that the Celtics more than willingly gave up their best player, making them arguably the dumbest braintrust of the offseason. So the only reason they didn't get a flat F is because they were able to acquire Mitchell Robinson, i.e. the most-consequential 2026 free agent within the context of the Wemby era (tho of course he's no replacement for Jaylen Brown). Also, even though Paul George gets dissed a lot these days, dude can still score. So it's not like the last couple of months have been all bad.
But that said, what's really making the Celtics look ass backwards is the fact that a few of their main (conference) competitors have gotten noticeably better, while they have rather downgraded, so to speak. Even a C-, all things considered, may be generous. They must really, really, really be looking forward to Payton Pritchard taking a major step forward this coming season.
BROOKLYN NETS: C-
I'm looking forward to Porter Jr. + Randle being one of the better F combinations next season. But damn, the rest of the roster has virtually zero name recognition. This has to be, like by far, the least-popular team in the league, which is pretty amazing when you consider all of the hype surrounding Brooklyn a few years back. Where's Jigga when you need him?
One of the biggest problems with the Nets, not even looking back at the past, is that they've come to rely too heavily on young, unproven players. But at the same time, the braintrust like sucks when it comes to drafting. So speaking of non-stars needing to take a major step forward next season, man. Porter + Randle may be formidable, but if other guys don't overachieve, forget about it.
If anything, I guess we can say that Brooklyn needs to solidly lock that pair down, so at least they have a set foundation to build on. If they do trade Porter Jr. like really, who are they going to get return to stand at the center of a young rebuild?
NEW YORK KNICKS: C+
Giving NYK a C may be generous because, in reality, they downgraded this offseason. In terms of all-around talent, they still have the best starting five in the league. But honestly, if not for their bench overachieving, it's unlikely they would have won that championship.
Meanwhile, the Knicks have lost their most-notable bench player (to a direct competitor), that being Mitchell Robinson. Andre Drummond, despite being relatively slow and kinda one-dimensional, isn't a slouch. He's also a better rebounder than Robinson. But it's like, yeah. When Wemby comes to town, there's going to be a problem.
But at least the Knicks were able to keep all of the rest of their dudes, and at least the team hasn't gotten smaller while the rest of league is sizing up. But as it currently stands, given that latter fact, i.e. competitors getting bigger or deeper, I'm not overly confident they will repeat. Also, it does look like the powers-that-be assisted them in winning, and there's no guarantee they'll get that favor again.
PHILADELPHIA 76ERS: A
I can't give the Sixers an A+ because despite having the most-newsworthy offseason of 2026, they failed to address their biggest issue - the inconsistency of Embiid's health. They went out and got Brown plus Lebron "Donatello" James, the latter of whom, now willing to be paid like a NBA layman, ended up being the most-heavily recruited free agent. But there are a number of elephants in the room.
First of all, to reiterate, we can't rely on Joel being consistently available. Second, every other viable contender is bigger, i.e. taller, than Philly. And third, oh shit, they don't even have a backup center.
Meanwhile, the idea of Lebron playing smallball 5 is no longer valid because again, competitors are now too big besides LBJ, at his current age, sucking on defense. But since they are going to be forced to play smallball nonetheless, I have floated the idea of Ben Simmons, who can also play the 5, perhaps coming back.
That said, with or without Embiid, the Sixers should dominate other smaller teams. Also, we have to take into consideration that besides having a boatload of talent, these guys probably want to win more than anyone else. The energy is super exciting, to the point that losing is not an option..
TORONTO RAPTORS: F
The Raptors get an F for now for a couple of solid reasons. They tried to trade one of their star players, only for the transaction to be voided or whatever. That isn't ideal, because you have to presume that Ingram, despite always being in trade talks, feels at least a tad bit disgruntled. You try to trade someone, renege and then expect him to report to the organization and give his very best, even though his (multi-million dollar) salary has already been set. Okay.
But even more alarming is that, outside of that one failed and overall questionable move, dudes have made zero attempts to upgrade. Granted, Kawhi is definitely worth the wait or whatever. But if the trade ultimately doesn't go through, Toronto just completely wasted an offseason while, once again, the Eastern Conference at large has gotten better. And it's not like the Raptors are contenders already. That isn't admirable braintrusting.
CONCLUSION
The Atlantic should be one of the most interesting divisions next season, even if a couple of teams may be overrated. They have the reigning champions, as well Lebron and, even though he's switched teams, Jaylen has stuck around also. But there is balance in that the Nets, i.e. the least-interesting team in the NBA, is also present. And as for the Raptors, they may continue to be respectable even without Kawhi. But if he doesn't come to town, no one outside of Canada will really care to follow them.